What a disgrace.
Precisely 10 years ago (April 29, 1996) as gas prices reached a shocking
$1.27 a gallon, President Bill Clinton ordered his Energy and Justice
departments to launch investigations to find out why. In my column that
week, I offered a wild guess as to why: "supply is down and demand is
up." I offered Energy Secretary Hazel O'Leary and Attorney General Janet
Reno a $100 bet (I roll high on sure things) that their million-dollar
probes would do nothing more than confirm my hunch.
No takers. Even Cabinet secretaries don't throw away C-notes. Sure
enough, months later these perfectly pointless investigations discounted
charges of price gouging and attributed the price hike to . . .
increased demand and decreased supply.
Today, every time an Iranian mullah opens his mouth about nukes, the
risk premium for Persian Gulf supply interruptions jumps again. Crude
oil prices alone account for about $1.70 of what you pay for a gallon at
the pump. So 10 years later, I'll wager again. Here's what the Bush
search for price gougers and profiteers will find:
Demand is up. China has come from nowhere to pass Japan as the
number No. 2 oil consumer in the world. China and India — between them
home to eight times the U.S. population — are industrializing and
gobbling huge amounts of energy.
American demand is up because we've lived in a fool's paradise since the
mid-1980s. Until then, beginning with the oil shocks in 1973, Americans
had changed appliances and cars and habits and achieved astonishing
energy conservation. Energy use per dollar of gross domestic product was
cut by 30 percent in little over a decade. Oil prices collapsed to about
$10 a barrel.
Then amnesia set in, mile-per-gallon ratings disappeared from TV ads and
we became "a country of a million Walter Mittys driving 75 mph in their
gas-guzzling Bushwhack-Safari sport-utility roadsters with a moose head
on the hood, a country whose crude oil production has dropped 32 percent
in the last 25 years but which will not drill for oil in the Arctic
National Wildlife Refuge for fear of disturbing the mating habits of
caribou."
I wrote that during the '96 witch hunt for price gougers. Nothing has
changed. Except that since then, U.S. crude oil production has dropped
an additional 12.3 percent. Which brings us to:
Supply is down. Start with supply disruptions in Nigeria,
decreased production in Iraq, and the continuing loss of 5 percent of
our national refining capacity because of damage from hurricanes Katrina
and Rita. Add to that the mischief of idiotic new regulations. Last
year's energy bill mandates arbitrary increases in blended ethanol use
that so exceed current ethanol production that it is causing gasoline
shortages and therefore huge price spikes.
Why don't we import the missing ethanol? Brazil makes a ton of it, and
very cheaply. Answer: the Iowa caucuses. Iowa grows corn and chooses
presidents. So we have a ridiculously high 54-cent ethanol tariff and
ethanol shortages.
Another regulation requires specific ("boutique") gasoline blends for
different cities depending on their air quality. Nice idea. But it
introduces debilitating rigidities into the gasoline supply system. If
Los Angeles runs short, you cannot just move supply in from Denver. You
get shortages and more price spikes.
And don't get me started on the missing supply of might-have-been
American crude. Arctic and outer continental shelf oil that the
politicians kill year after year would have provided us by now with a
critical and totally secure supply cushion in times of tight markets.
In March 2000, the price of gas hit $1.80 per gallon. Scandalized
congressional Republicans shamelessly pushed for repeal of Clinton's
whopping 4.3-cent gas tax increase. Now that the president is a
Republican, what do you think Senate Democrats are proposing? A 60-day
suspension of the federal gas tax. It would cost $6 billion and
counteract the only good thing that comes with high gas prices — the
incentive to conserve.
George Shultz once said, "Nothing ever gets settled in this town." But
even Shultz, who has seen everything, must marvel at the perfect
regularity, the utter predictability, of the bottomless cynicism of
Washington in the grip of gasoline fever.